Proposal to Najenda[]
This is the conversation which took place in my wall following B214's and my deletion of his supposed proposal to Najenda.
User:NewGenTV - That's clearly Syura, aside from the appearance he even mentions that he's of royal blood.
- User:CoquidragonNope, it is not so clear which is why B214 deleted it, and after my restoring it, I saw my error and agree with B214. It could be him, true, but facial features and clothing might point to somebody else. Besides, Syura is not of royal blood. Honest is the prime minister. He is not a member of the Royal Family. If the person indeed is of royal blood, more reasons against it being Syura. I don't want to undo the deletion twice, can you please undo your own change?
- If you want further discussion, bring the question to the talk page at Syura's article. For the time being, I agree with User:B214 in his deletion of this comment.
- User:NewGenTV - To each their own, but I still say he's Syura, unless some other information about him pops up in the later chapters. Though, we don't know for sure if Honest has some blood ties with the young king.
- User:Coquidragon - The problem is not where he is or isn't, but wether it is confirmed or not, which for wikia is the same thing. Nowhere does his name appear. To say it is him, It is speculation at best. Besides, the one indicator, "royal blood," goes against it. It would be also unfounded speculation to attribute royal blood to Honest. We only know he is the prime minister. Nothing else, nothing more. Based on this, this comments speculates on this unnamed character, based on another speculation of Honest being of royal blood. Where do we draw the line?
- User:NewGenTV - I was simply pointing out that there's a possibility he might be of royal blood, he does resemble Syura a lot. It's not a far-fetched speculation, when the mystery man resembles him highly.
- User:Coquidragon - Whether "far-fetched" or not, it is still speculation, and shouldn't go on the article. We can speculate in Blogs, Forums and Talk pages, but not on the articles themselves.
Well i suppose this ends the issue of that. 二B214 一 Talk四14:59,11/16/2014
Comparison to Scar[]
Anyone else see a look alike between Syura and Scar from Fullmetal Alchemist Epic gammer (talk) 02:12, November 19, 2015 (UTC)
Excluding the animator's art style, not one bit. Neither in appearance nor character. Also, use threads for this, talk pages are solely for article discussion.NewGenTV (talk) 02:30, November 19, 2015 (UTC)